Lead Forensics

RMBS in the UK and Italy: Same product, different risks

Stay informed via our mailing list

subscribe

Introduction

Mortgage risk isn’t just about the borrower – it’s about the country, the legal framework and the economy behind it. This research report examines how two differing jurisdictions, the UK and Italy, fit within ARC’s broader RMBS framework, highlighting the key differences that drive probability of default (PD) and recovery rate assumptions.

ARC calculated ten-year average house price to income (HPI) ratios of over 8x in many UK regions, stretching affordability compared to Italy where HPI ratios generally average 4-7x. Differences such as these reinforce the need for ARC’s tailored approaches for assessing RMBS risk in different jurisdictions.

Key Points

  • Establishing the Baseline PDs: ARC’s RMBS methodology begins with establishing baseline PDs and property valuations, which vary on a jurisdiction by jurisdiction basis. The relationship between LTV and default levels, along with differences in underwriting standards, distinguish the baseline PDs assumed for the UK and Italy.
  • Baseline PD Adjustments: These baseline PDs are then adjusted to reflect borrower, loan and property-specific factors. ARC observed high DTI ratios have a stronger effect on default levels in the UK compared to Italy, increasing the PD penalties compared to Italy in most cases.
  • Calculating Recoveries: ARC establishes base valuation and market value decline assumptions for each property, before making adjustments to reflect additional risk factors. For example, ARC applied higher forced sale valuation stresses in Italy due to properties typically being sold for 20-30% below market value in auction[1].

 

[1]      Available at: Idealista News | Italy’s top properties for sale at auction

Documents

Arc Ratings - Download Document

RMBS in the UK and Italy: Same Product, Different Risks

25 Mar 2025

Contacts

Analytical

Arc Ratings - Jake Shoer
Arc Ratings - Ashley Thomas

Business development

Arc Ratings - Jason Barrass
Arc Ratings - Rhonda Moore

Latest ratings